Skip to main content

Why too much medical treatment is causing more harm than good

Broadcast 
Space to play or pause, M to mute, left and right arrows to seek, up and down arrows for volume.
Doctor looking at x-ray
Doctors are recommending too many unhelpful, and possibly harmful, scans and x-rays, says surgeon Ian Harris.(Getty Images)

Much of medicine doesn't do what it is supposed to do: improve health.

That is the view of orthopaedic surgeon, Ian Harris.

He believes too many drugs are being prescribed, too much surgery is being performed, and there are too many unhelpful tests, scans, and overdiagnosis.

The 'business' of medicine, Ian says, is taking precedence over what the science tells us.

We should go back to the first principles of the Hippocratic oath and 'first, do no harm'.

Ian Harris talks to Paul Barclay

Recorded at the Williamstown Literary Festival on June 19, 2022.

Originally broadcast on July 6, 2022.

Speaker

Ian Harris — Sydney based orthopaedic surgeon; Professor of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of NSW; co-author, Hippocrasy

  • Presenter / producer – Paul Barclay
  • Sound Engineer – David Le May
Broadcast 
Medical Ethics, Surgical Medicine, Doctors and Medical Professionals
QR code image for downloading the ABC listen app

Discover more podcasts

Download the ABC listen app to hear more of your favourite podcasts